In Ontario’s competitive real estate market, a signed Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS) signifies a binding commitment between a buyer and a seller. However, what happens when the buyer fails to deliver the deposit stipulated in the agreement? While some buyers may believe that skipping the deposit allows them to walk away from the deal, the reality is far more complex. Failing to deliver a deposit can have significant legal consequences, which this blog post will explore.
The Nature of the Deposit in Real Estate Transactions
A deposit in real estate transactions serves as a sign of good faith and commitment to the agreement. It demonstrates the buyer’s intention to proceed with the transaction and provides the seller with a measure of security. However, the deposit is not the “consideration” that makes the contract legally binding. Instead, the mutual promises exchanged by the buyer and seller (i.e., the promise to transfer the property in exchange for the purchase price) form the legal consideration.
Importantly, most standard real estate agreements in Ontario, such as the Ontario Real Estate Association (OREA) forms, are executed under seal. This means that even without consideration, the agreement remains binding once signed by both parties.
Failing to Pay the Deposit Is a Breach of Contract
When a buyer fails to deliver the deposit as required by the APS, they are in breach of contract. This breach entitles the seller to specific legal remedies, including:
1. Termination of the Agreement
The seller may choose to terminate the APS, allowing them to re-list the property and seek a new buyer. However, this decision does not absolve the buyer of their obligations under the original agreement.
2. Suing for Damages
The seller has the right to sue the buyer for damages resulting from the breach. These damages may include the difference between the original purchase price and the resale price if the property is sold for less. Additionally, the seller can claim incidental costs, such as additional carrying costs or legal fees.
3. Claiming the Deposit (Even If Unpaid)
Courts in Ontario have upheld that deposits act as liquidated damages in real estate transactions. Even if the buyer never physically delivered the deposit, the seller may still sue for the amount of the agreed-upon deposit. The rationale is that the deposit represents a pre-estimate of the seller’s losses in the event of a breach.
4. Pursuing Specific Performance
In some cases, the seller may seek a court order for specific performance, compelling the buyer to complete the transaction. This remedy is rare and reserve for specific scenarios.
Practical Considerations for Buyers and Sellers
For Buyers:
Understand Your Obligations: A signed APS is legally binding. Ensure you are financially prepared to fulfill the terms of the agreement, including paying the deposit.
Consult Legal Counsel Early: If circumstances arise that make it difficult to proceed with the transaction, seek legal advice promptly to explore your options.
For Sellers:
Act Quickly: If a buyer fails to deliver the deposit, consult with a lawyer immediately to understand your rights and the appropriate next steps.
Avoid Signing a Mutual Release Prematurely: Signing a mutual release may waive your right to pursue damages or the deposit. Carefully consider the implications before taking this step.
Case Law Insights
Ontario courts have consistently reinforced the enforceability of deposit provisions in real estate contracts. For example, in Tang v. Zhang (2013), the Ontario Superior Court of Justice held that the buyer’s failure to pay the deposit constituted a breach of contract, and the seller was entitled to claim the full deposit amount as liquidated damages. This case underscores the principle that a deposit represents a genuine pre-estimate of damages and is enforceable even if the seller does not suffer a measurable loss.
Key Takeaways
Failing to deliver a deposit is a serious breach of contract with significant legal consequences.
Buyers should not assume that withholding a deposit absolves them of their obligations under the APS.
Sellers have multiple remedies, including termination, suing for damages, or pursuing specific performance.
Consulting with a real estate lawyer early can help both parties navigate disputes effectively.
At Weedon Law, we specialize in Ontario real estate litigation and can assist buyers and sellers in understanding their rights and obligations. If you have questions about deposit disputes or other real estate matters, contact us to schedule a consultation.
Comments